dubstep History · Nyc · essay 001

Dub War

The five years New York City had it first.


If you’ve been to a Dubstep show anywhere in this country~any show, any size, any sub-genre~you can draw a line from that room back to the basement of a bar in Bed-Stuy.

Three rooms · Five years

Sputnik

Bed-Stuy, Brooklyn

June 2005

Rothko

Lower East Side, Manhattan

November 2005

Love

Greenwich Village, Manhattan

May 2007

Ended June 2010

And I’m not just glazing my own city here… even though it is the greatest city in the world. Between June 2005 and June 2010, a party called Dub War hosted the first American performances of Kode9, Mala, Loefah and Skream. And when they played their first West Coast shows they flew on flights the founders of Dub War paid for half of. When the people who invented this sound first came to the States, Dub War was typically the reason. For almost exactly five years, if you wanted to hear this music the way it was made to be heard, there was only one room in the country that existed for that sole purpose.

Most Americans who love Dubstep today have never even heard of Dub War~me included. As much as I love this city and this scene, I didn’t know how much of Dubstep’s history happened here until earlier this summer, when I came back from my first Denver trip with one question: why Denver? That’s the gap I aim to close with this piece.

Dub War ran for five years across three rooms: the basement of Sputnik in Bed-Stuy, then Rothko in the Lower East Side, then Love, a basement club off Washington Square Park that it settled into on May 19, 2007.

Dub War wasn’t a party about who was playing. It was a five year argument about what a room owes the people standing in it.

A note on sources

I am no journalist and I interviewed no one for this. Everything I’ve written comes from two amazing pieces: Ali Gitlow’s oral history for Red Bull Music Academy Daily in 2016 and Laurent Fintoni’s for FACT in 2015 + my own digging around them. Both are linked at the bottom.

The Internet, Dave Q, Joe Nice, and the London Connection

First, where this music actually came from

If you’re like me, the first time you heard dubstep it was Skrillex. That version, the version the bulk of this country met first, is a later chapter in a book that begins somewhere else entirely. The sound that would later be labeled dubstep first sprouted in the early 2000s out of Croydon, a South London borough that most Londoners think of as the suburbs and the rest of us should think of as the dubstep capital of the world. An experimental fusion of Garage, Grime, and Jamaican Sound System culture, the sound came from producers who kept stripping the vocals and brightness out of tracks until all that was left was skippy drums and room for a new kind of low-end to punch through. No one called it dubstep at the time. Just dark garage, or “the sound.”

This piece does not exist to chronicle the history of dubstep in the UK. That’s been done exhaustively~most recently by Lauren Martin in Aftershock: The Seismic Impact of Dubstep; go read it~BUT, this story simply does not hit the same without some basic knowledge.

If you’re reading this, I’m sure you’ve at least heard of the people that will come up in this retelling, so we’ll focus on the three places that matter more than the rest:

Big Apple Records, a record shop in Croydon where Hatcha and Artwork worked the counter and a teenage Skream and Benga came in to hawk tracks they’d made every now and then. If dubstep has a birthplace, it’s this record shop.

FWD>>, a regular night at Plastic People in East London that ran from 2001 and was, for years, the first and only club in the world where you could reliably hear this sound. The crowd was mostly the people making the music. If Big Apple is the birthplace, FWD>> is where it stopped being a sound and became a scene.

DMZ, started in Brixton in March 2005, run by four friends: Mala and Coki [together: Digital Mystikz], Loefah, and Sarge Pokes. Dub War was its American counterpart in almost every sense.

And for my head-banging and 4×4-genre-loving friends… no, not that Malaa. MALA, as in Mark Lawrence, half of Digital Mystikz, founder of the label Deep Medi Musik, and arguably the single most respected producer in the history of the genre. The whole South London scene ran on a philosophy printed on every DMZ flyer: come meditate on bass weight. And they meant it. The point was that you went to experience frequencies you feel in your body, in a dark room, with the DJ standing at the same level as you. A model for a room that will resurface in Greenwich Village, Manhattan in 2007.

A Few Hundred People, a Message Board, and a Dream

Here’s the thing about dubstep that flies under the radar: it grew in tandem with the modern internet, and it could not have exploded the way it did even a few years earlier.

Blackdown // Martin Clark, the writer who chronicled this scene in real time for Pitchfork and on his own blog, puts it about as plainly as can be:

It is a historical fact that the emergence of the Internet as a force coincides with the emergence of dubstep. In 2000, in England, we’re really talking about dial-up Internet: when Web pages took 30 seconds to load, and before MP3’s existed. Fast forward five years and you’re starting to get faster connections, and it increased the rate at which people could communicate across the Atlantic.

The key piece of infrastructure that made Dub War possible was a forum called dubplate.net where a few hundred people would log on every day to argue about tunes and tell each other what was worth buying. Before dubstep fans had reddit, twitter, or even a name for this music they liked, it had this forum.

dubplate.net wasn’t the last of them either. In October 2005, a few months after DMZ’s first dance and Dub War’s first night, Ivan Kovacevic [aka Dubway] founded dubstepforum, which spent the next decade as the scene’s town square until it shut down in 2015. Thankfully, the site is still up as an archive, because those threads are the closest thing to a first-hand record this party has. The couple of things the two articles couldn’t tell me, I found there.

That’s the part that’s hard to convey to the modern fan. If you lived outside London~and for a stretch, NYC~these forums were the scene. There were maybe a handful of North Americans on dubplate.net. Two of them started Dub War.

Dave Q

Dave Quintiliani, more commonly known as Dave Q, moved to New York in 1998 to work in advertising. Self-proclaimed as more of a collector than a DJ, he frequented the city’s circuit of Drum and Bass nights and found himself becoming progressively more disappointed with where drum and bass was headed as it got faster, cleaner, and more technical. It was during this phase of his life that a stranger on a message board recommended he check out “Battle” by Wookie. They described the track as dark garage.

It checked a lot of boxes for things I loved about drum and bass but also house and R&B.

That track sent him down a rabbit hole into the deeper, darker side of UKG, which led him to a little-known forum called dubplate.net, where he first started talking to the people in London who were making the music. And he wasn’t the only North American dipping their toes into the scene through this forum. The other two were Joe Nice, a DJ in Baltimore, and Kuma, a DJ/promoter in Vancouver. That was more or less the continent.

In 2001 Dave flew to London for the first time. Not for dubstep, but to hear drum and bass in its hometown at a night called Movement. Before he went, he reached out to Kode9 through the forum to ask where he could hear this new dark garage sound in person. Kode9 told him there was nothing going on while he’s in town. I wonder why he didn’t send him to FWD>>, which started at Plastic People the same year. My guess is FWD>> hadn’t started yet or it would be the equivalent of me telling a NYC tourist who expressed moderate interest in electronic music that they should go to Basement before they leave. The latter is funnier, and none of my reading proved otherwise, so we’ll go with that.

And then there’s this part that still gets me: Mass, where he went for that drum and bass night, is the main room at St Matthew’s Church, a venue in Brixton. On the ground floor of that same venue was a room called Third Base. Four years later, four South Londoners would put down a deposit and make Third Base the home of the inaugural DMZ dance.

In 2001, Dave Q flew across an ocean for a completely different genre and stood inside the building that would house the party that changed his life. He had no idea. Nobody did.

When he wasn’t recovering from his London nights, he did what a collector does. He went record shopping. Specifically, he went to Blackmarket~a legendary record shop in London’s Soho~and found J Da Flex working the counter, who is one of the early pioneers of the garage mutants that became dubstep. He left with a bag of records.

He did find that dark garage sound he was looking for though:

I was wandering around Brixton in the morning and found this place at the back of a grocery store that was playing music, a dark room with a sound system. I stepped into this world I knew nothing about and it affected me deeply. If it wasn’t for that, everything that came after probably wouldn’t have happened.

Even the grocery stores have great sound systems in London. Imagine walking into a random bodega here that not only had a legitimate soundsystem~already unlikely~but was playing anything remotely close to bass music.

Joe Nice, and what a dubplate actually is

Joe Nice got there by the same mechanism, in a different medium.

A friend gave him a UK garage box set to listen to and the harder, more percussive tracks buried in those mixes kept piquing his interest so he started working backwards to figure out who was making them. That exercise repeatedly pointed him at one record shop in Croydon: Big Apple Records. So he emailed them to place an order. Then he did it again. And again and again for months, ordering records, until the guy answering the emails knew who he was before he’d put a face or a voice to the name. That guy answering the emails was Hatcha:

A lot of the time, when you would email the store, the person responding was Hatcha. When I met him for the first time, we already knew who each other were.

Hatcha, the resident DJ at FWD>> and the man most responsible for what the first wave of this genre sounded like, was answering the shop’s customer emails. Gotta love it. By 2002 Joe had played alongside him in Baltimore, making him the first DJ in America genuinely tapped into the South London scene.

Then he did something almost nobody outside London was doing: he started cutting his own dubplates.

Dubplates: Decoded for the Modern Raver

Dubplates were the physical embodiment of what you refer to as an ID today. Before the days of CDJs [and that fucking sync button], if you had an unreleased song that you wanted your DJ friends to test it in a room, you’d email them the file~then instead of the typical import to rekordbox, export to usb [and everything in between] workflow we all know, and don’t necessarily love, today~they’d email that file to their cutting studio of choice, pay them to lathe that single track onto a blank acetate disc, and go pick it up when they could. One copy, cut by hand, for that DJ only.

A couple truths about the nature of dubplates reveal how for the culture this guy was. First, the process described above is expensive and tedious. Second, unlike the hard vinyl that’s used to press commercial records, acetate is soft. A dubplate physically degrades every time you play it. After enough plays it’s just white noise. So a dubplate is a record that costs real money, has a finite number of plays, and might be one of only a handful on the planet.

In sound system culture~which is where all of this ultimately descends from, and we’ll get to that~a dubplate, like an ID today, is your most valuable asset. Having something that nobody else has is the whole point.

Joe Nice funded his own. In America. In 2003. So much so that Mala had this to say about him in Fintoni’s piece:

Joe had access to everybody’s dubs. There wasn’t anybody who was holding off tunes from Joe Nice ‘cos he was just that guy. Lovely guy. Deeply passionate about the music and not afraid to express himself.

That’s a founder of DMZ saying that a guy in Baltimore had the run of London’s unreleased music. Here’s what that sounded like in a room, from FaltyDL~who came up as a Dub War regular before he was ever on the bill~describing Joe batting cleanup, what Joe labeled going on as the last DJ of the night:

He would play 10-inch dubplates that he was getting cut in the UK, and there was all this mystical business going on around his sets, but the first time the beat dropped in his set I felt the bass in my chest and it knocked the shit out of me.

Joe had the records and relationships. Dave was about to get the room. Neither one of them makes Dub War alone.

The two finally met in person at a rare NYC appearance by Benny Ill of Horsepower Productions, another figure crucial to dubstep’s early development who once recorded under an alias that will become very important to this story in about thirty seconds.

Before Dub War was Dub War

Like the music that prompted it, the party existed before it had a name.

There’s a pre-history to Dub War. Cliff aka DJ Seoul runs Direct Drive, a drum and bass night. When he was doing his party at Rothko he started booking me to play in the basement, which was when I started playing dubstep out. They were crazy for it, so he kept booking me until to the point where it almost felt like Room 2 at Rothko was the unofficial Dub War room. It went on like that for about six months before I finally was like, “Let me try one of my own.” That’s when Joe and I linked up and started it in Brooklyn, at Sputnik.

Six months of a drum and bass crowd going off for a genre that barely had a name yet, in a venue that would later become one of Dub War’s homes. Dub War wasn’t founded so much as it outgrew being a side room at some one else’s party. The room kept filling up until the guy playing it had no choice but to go start his own thing.

And the name? Well, in 2001, Benny Ill~the same Benny Ill whose New York show is where Dave and Joe first shook hands~put out a 12-inch on Tempa with Bill Robbins, under a new alias name they came up with: Dub War.

In a way, they named the party after the man who first brought them together. That’s the kind of detail that exists only in a scene small enough that every one knows every one.

The Spark

What finally tipped the scales wasn’t a record though. It was DMZ.

It all came together for me. It was musical but also philosophical. It captured the essence of what drew me to the sound. Ever since 9/11 there had been an absence of something with depth and feeling. DMZ was kinda political in a non-political way – subversive, intelligent, all these things that had been missing from music for me for a lot of years.

This was a New York where the club scene had taken a serious hit, where a lot of what was left felt thin, and where a guy in advertising was watching a genre he’d loved for a decade turn into something he didn’t recognize. What he’s describing isn’t nostalgia. It’s a void. Then a spark, dazzling from some 3,500 miles away, that lit the way.

It was insane to me that this vibration hadn’t spread outwards yet, and that was the strongest impetus to start Dub War. People here needed to know about what these people were saying, the music they were making and the community they were building. Dub War was simply a way to play that music to a room of people in New York.

That’s the whole founding ethos, right there. Not a business plan. A guy who discovered something and couldn’t believe no one around him had heard about it yet.

Sputnik

Sometime in June 2005, three months after DMZ’s first dance in Brixton, Dave booked the basement of Sputnik; a bar in Bed-Stuy he knew from seeing hip-hop DJs play there. Guys like Rich Medina, a Philly // New York selector best known for a long-running Fela Kuti party called Jump N Funk, and Evil Dee, the producer/DJ behind Black Moon and half of Beatminerz. America’s first Dubstep night took place in a basement where the regulars had come up on Brooklyn hip-hop.

This is the birthplace. The basement of a bar in Brooklyn. I am being pedantic because Love, the Manhattan room Dub War is remembered for, gets so much of the credit that people misremember it as the origin. It wasn’t. It came two years later.

Gitlow’s piece and Fintoni’s piece both call Dub War the first dubstep night in America. The version I’d confidently defend is the narrower one: the first regular, dedicated dubstep club night in the United States. Not the first time anyone ever played a dubstep record here or the first time a group of people gathered in front of a DJ playing dubstep here~that would be impossible to prove. But the first room that existed for dubstep, and dubstep only, on a regular schedule.

Gitlow’s piece says Dub War ran monthly. Fintoni’s puts the fifth installment in April 2006, eleven months after launch. I was curious so I looked deeper and found the original announcement on dubstepforum [DUB WAR III — Kode 9, Joe Nice — Friday, November 18th, 2005 — Rothko] with posts from Dave, Joe, and their MC the afternoon of the party. Take the roman numeral at face value and the first year lines up: first installment in June 2005, third in November, fifth the following April.

The MC

Dub War’s MC found the party the same way its founders found the music.

Juakali was transitioning out of the hip-hop and spoken-word scenes~a poet and vocalist, not a traditional MC~and he had a niche obsession: he kept hearing records that sampled Caribbean vocals, and he wanted to know who was making them. So he did the only thing he could think of in 2005 and started emailing strangers:

Out of the hundreds of emails I sent out I got like 30 responses, and Dave Q was one of them: “I’m thinking about playing some music out at this spot called Sputnik.” I went to Pratt Institute, which is two blocks away from Sputnik, so I said that I’d stop by.

Hundreds of emails. Thirty replies. One of them a guy planning a party two blocks from where he was living for art school.

That’s the third instance of the same mechanism in this story. Dave found the music through a message board. Joe found it by emailing a record shop until the man who defined the sound wrote back. Juakali found the party by cold-emailing several hundred people. Nobody in this story was scouted, hired, or introduced by anybody with a job title. They typed into the dark and someone typed back.

What Juakali did on the mic is worth explaining too, because “MC” culture is virtually non-existent in America. Joe Nice describes it as hosting and toasting rather than rapping: reading the room, riding the space between drops, holding energy through transitions, rather than delivering written bars. It’s the sound system tradition, straight out of Jamaica and through UK jungle and garage. He’d be on the mic six to eight hours a night.

As a MC, what surprised me about that party was that he was completely in tune with what we were doing. There were times where I felt that he was selecting tunes I could actually spit bars on.

And when the guests came, he learned to read them:

When I played with the guests, they knew I wouldn’t overpower their mixing. Sometimes, they would be like, “No, I want you all over this!”

Sputnik’s basement was small. That was fine. It was still more people than had ever gathered in America for this sole purpose. And people loved it. But after the second event, an email arrived from Glasgow that made the room seem even smaller.

The Move to Rothko

Kode9 // Steve Goodman, founder of the Hyperdub label, the man who would go on to release Burial, got in touch after the second Sputnik event. He was assembling a US tour and he wanted to play Dub War.

There was no way Sputnik’s basement could hold a Kode9 crowd. The move was painless though, because Dave already knew exactly where to go: Rothko, in LES, the same venue where he would regularly play the basement of Direct Drive’s dnb party two years earlier. This time the party was his, it was in the main room, and on Friday, November 18th, 2005, it was where Kode9 played the first American show of his career. Mala, Loefah and Skream all followed.

On paper it was a serious upgrade. Mid-2000s LES. Massive ceilings, ruby red walls, a wooden DJ booth you could move around like an art car.

The soundsystem, on the other hand:

I do remember the soundsystem wasn’t all that at Rothko. I’d traveled enough trying to play this music since 2003 or 2004 to realize that, if the soundsystem wasn’t there, it just sounded shit; it sounded empty. It’s not that it was bass-driven music, it was sub-driven music. I played on enough shit soundsystems to realize that it wasn’t all roses outside of London.

That’s not a bad review. That’s the entire problem stated in one paragraph, by someone qualified to state it~and it’s the first time in this story the room fails the people standing in it.

Why the rig is the whole argument

This is where dubstep’s actual ancestry matters because, this music’s oldest descendent is Jamaican sound system culture, not any form of dance music. And in Jamaica from the 1950s on, a sound system was something a crew built, owned, and competed on: custom speaker stacks, custom amplification, built and tuned by hand, then hauled to an empty lot or hall, and set-up for a dance. That tradition traveled with Caribbean immigration to London, ran through Notting Hill Carnival, and evolved into jungle, garage, and eventually dubstep. The language your local 140 kids love to spew~selector… dubplate… wheel-up… rewind… bombaclat~is all borrowed from it.

The practical consequence is the thing Kode9 is complaining about. Sub-bass is the frequency range roughly below 60Hz. You don’t really hear it; you feel it, in your chest, your legs, and the floor. Your typical club PA system physically cannot reproduce it. And if you try to play dubstep on one of these rigs, it doesn’t just sound quieter. It sounds hollow. The part of the track that carries the entire emotional payload is simply absent.

Which means booking the right room isn’t production value. It’s the difference between playing the music and not playing it.

[NYC’s clearest living example of this is Dub-Stuy, the Bed-Stuy collective that launched in 2012 and hand-built its own rig, the Tower of Sound. That’s a piece of its own and it’s coming.]

So what did Dub War do about Rothko’s sound system over the next eighteen months? Well, nothing, because you can’t replace the sound system in a venue you don’t own. They ran the room they had the best they could, took a detour through a converted church when the city forced one, and then in 2007, departed for a basement in Greenwich Village that had been built by people who understood the problem. That’s the answer, and it’s the reason Love matters as much as it does.

Before that, though, Rothko gave them two nights worth telling.

In late January 2006, Mala flew over and became Dub War’s second international guest. On the night he played he was joined by London MCs Jammer, Skepta, and D Double E, who happened to be in town. Three foundational grime figures, in a dubstep room, in Manhattan, by coincidence. Grime and Dubstep grew out of the same pirate radio ecosystem in London and had always been cousins, but this was the first time that relationship showed up in New York. Both Kode9 and Mala went home with nothing but good things to say about what Dave and Joe were building.

Two months later, Dave and Joe returned the favor by flying to London for DMZ’s first birthday:

There was a lot of respect at DMZ coming from people who’d heard what an experience Dub War was. It was an immediate sense of family with the core people there.

Third Base hit its 400-person capacity within an hour of opening, with close to double that still outside. They moved the party upstairs to Mass, the same room Dave stood in five years earlier for drum and bass.

The last DJ to play DMZ in that little downstairs room, signing off an era, was our boy Joe Nice. And when Skream closed the night upstairs from the raised, church-like booth, Dave remembers thinking for the first time that this could end up being much bigger than any of them had imagined.

The Day Rothko Got Shut Down

The fifth installment of Dub War took place just a few months later in April 2006. This time, Loefah and Sarge Pokes, two of DMZ’s founders, were billed, and on flights from London that Dave had paid for.

However, Dub War was about to be put through their first spin cycle. The night before the event, Blues Traveler packed 750 people into Rothko’s 400-cap room, prompting the fire marshal to shut the whole venue down. And Dub War, with Loefah and Pokes already paid for and in the air, had no room for them.

I’d just paid for two international flights and I had no venue.

Fintoni notes that he said this with a nervous laugh, twenty years later, which tells you roughly how funny it was at the time. Two men are somewhere over the Atlantic. There is no backup room. This is a party run by a guy with a full-time job in advertising and a mailing list.

The person who saved them was DJ Seoul, the drum and bass DJ/Promoter who booked Dave in Rothko’s basement before Dub War existed. He made some calls and found them a room for that same night.

Here’s the part I’d have paid to see the faces on. The room he secured for them was the chapel at Avalon. Which, until two years prior, was more famously known as Limelight.

For those who don’t know: Limelight was a deconsecrated Episcopal church on the corner of 6th and 20th, turned nightclub by Peter Gatien in 1983. And for fifteen years it was one of the most notorious venues in America~the Club Kids, the Michael Alig case, federal drug indictments, the entire New York City nightlife mythology in one venue. By the time Dub War needed saving, it had been renamed and remodeled.

So: two founders of DMZ, the most reverent party in dubstep, played their New York show in the chapel of an old church that used to be the most infamous nightclub in the country, because a jungle promoter made a few calls. I’ve read a lot of scene history in my research for this piece, but that is by far the most NYC-coded sequence of events I’ve come across.

They returned to Avalon a few months later for Dub War’s first birthday, where they snuck in a then-underage Skream. That’s also the night Hank Shocklee showed up while Dave was working the door.

Shocklee is a founding member of The Bomb Squad~the production team behind Public Enemy’s It Takes a Nation of Millions to Hold Us Back and Fear of a Black Planet~which is to say he is not a guy who wanders into parties.

I couldn’t believe he was there. It was the first time I realised New York music people who I really respected were paying attention.

A few days later Shocklee called and asked them to lunch:

We met up and had some very interesting conversations with this complete stranger who totally understood what we were dealing with. Surreal experience. Everything is time, everything is place.

He became a regular. And a year later, he played his first set at Dub War as part of The Bomb Squad.

Love

In 2007 Dub War made its final migration to Love in Greenwich Village, where it stayed until the end. The inaugural night was May 19, 2007~Kode9, Badawi debuting original material, and Shackleton’s first US show~and it doubled as an announcement: a new venue, a night that now ran till 6AM, and a fixed monthly cadence: the third Saturday of every month. This is where Dub War stopped being sporadic and became a pillar of the NYC scene.

Love was built as an homage to the Paradise Garage~another iconic NYC club, that ran from 1977 to 1987 with Larry Levan as its resident DJ, and which is more or less where modern dance music culture originated. The Garage was famous for two things: a crowd that came for the music rather than to be seen, and a sound system so good that people made pilgrimages to hear it. Love was built by people trying to recreate that environment.

Fun fact

The club’s name is also where “garage house” as a genre label comes from. Decades later, when a completely different sound emerged out of UK sound system and jungle culture, producers borrowed that same word for what became UK garage, so two genres with almost no shared bloodline end up sharing a name purely because of Larry Levan’s residency at one Kings Street basement.

Dub War got in there through DB, a London transplant and founding member of N.A.S.A. [one of New York’s first rave crews]. Which means the torch wasn’t just inherited~it was passed, old school to new, in the form of a room.

From the street it was unassuming. A basement club behind a plain black door with no sign on it. NYU, chain restaurants, and banks all around, in a neighborhood that had long since stopped being the one that produced the Beat poets and punks. Dubstep had no real reason to be there. But by then, people were traveling to Dub War from far outside the five boroughs, and for them, as it still is today, downtown Manhattan was simply the easiest place to get to.

Kode9’s read of the room stuck with me:

In a way, that room was like EDM waiting to happen. I think Love was why the scene kicked off in New York. Love for Dub War was like Plastic People for FWD, but the vibe at Dub War was exciting because they were doing it in a very different way to how people were doing it in London. They’d get excited in a different way. Americans are weird like that.

Love for Dub War was like Plastic People for FWD>>. That’s the highest compliment available in this entire story. FWD>> at Plastic People [as you now know] is where dubstep discovered itself. Kode9 is confirming that New York finally had its equivalent.

A year before Love opened, the two nights had already shared a bill [Dub War vs FWD>> on September 30th, 2006 at Crash Mansion in Bowery]. Hatcha, the man who’d spent months answering Joe Nice’s emails to Big Apple Records, was also on the lineup. The London connection thread that opens this whole story, landing in Bowery on a Saturday night.

And Dub War wasn’t alone in that building. Love gave its Fridays over to bass music, one promoter per week: Sub Swara with world-beat first, DB and Dara’s Secret Night of Science for drum and bass, then Dub War, and on the fourth Friday of every month Trouble & Bass, where all the bass-music promoters came together to throw a joint party. What made it work wasn’t the schedule, it was the camaraderie of the promoters, who all went to each other’s nights. Gitlow’s piece takes the time to name the bartenders, the bouncers, and sound engineer and lighting tech Liz Liguori, as part of the community.

The moments people still bring up from that room are almost never about who was on the bill.

Someone dropping Kromestar’s “Kalawangi” and the room demanding it four or five times in a night.

Shackleton playing TRG’s “Broken Heart,” which people describe not as a moment the room went off but as the opposite. A basement full of people gone completely still. Meditating on bassweight, like their London counterpart.

And this story that felt criminal to leave out:

Q-Tip was there setting up because he had a party on Fridays. Loefah had just bought a synth and was carrying it with him in this bright orange case. Shocklee introduced them and Q-Tip was asking about the synth so Loefah took it out, hooked it up to the Love system and showed Tip how to make wobble bass.

Q-Tip, from A Tribe Called Quest [another defining voice in hip-hop] getting a tutorial on how to make a bass wobble from a founder of DMZ, introduced by a member of the Bomb Squad, in a basement in Greenwich Village. Dave calls it “a beautiful moment of these New York and London worlds colliding,” which is exactly what it is and still doesn’t do it justice.

The Booth

If you go and see a massive rock act at a huge stadium, they’re at arm’s length. They’re on a pedestal – something that you cannot be a part of. This is the opposite of the spirit of the dubstep community. At Love, the decks were on the same level as the crowd so you could see eye-to-eye. It had a “in it together” feeling, rather than a “look at me, I’m a superstar DJ” one, which is the vibe you get when the stakes get higher.

To be clear: this model for how a DJ booth should be set up relative to the crowd is a UK idea, brought to life in London first. That’s how FWD>> was set up as early as 2001, and DMZ was explicit about it from its first dance in 2005. Dark room, no lights, no VIP, DJs standing at eye level with the crowd. Mala’s words for why: “It was to allow people to be free in a way.”

What Love did was take that principle seriously enough to build an American room around it. That’s rarer than it sounds; plenty of American promoters imported the music and skipped the philosophy entirely. You can experience the results at almost every festival in the country.

The Sound System

Now, the lore around the sound system [which matters because of what I said earlier about rigs].

The story that circulated, and still circulates today, is that physical components of the Paradise Garage sound system were salvaged and installed at Love. This is not true, and the person who corrected it is the guy who ran the system: Andrew “Morphous” Eisele, Love’s sound engineer. According to Andrew, the rig was actually a custom Gary Stewart Audio build.

But this is one of those times where the truth is as cool as the legend. Stewart worked with Richard Long~the man who designed the Garage’s system~at the Paradise Garage, and took the design thinking with him when he founded his own company. So the lineage is real. It just traveled through a person instead of through a stack of cabinets.

Not a Purist Night

In true New York fashion, Dub War separated itself from its UK counterpart by being themselves, fostering local talent, and not worrying much about where the lines that defined dubstep fell when booking DJs. And when I say fostering local talent, I mean it. Guys like FaltyDL and Sepalcure, hailing from Connecticut and Brooklyn respectively, regularly attended Dub War as fans not too long before being on the lineups themselves. I’m sure they were DJs and electronic music fans who simply fell in love with this weird, fresh sound and tried to make it themselves, and Dave and Joe were tapped in, and open-minded enough, to give them a shot. And while neither classifies their music as dubstep today, both still have thriving careers.

Both of them credit their success to the room itself. Gitlow’s piece notes that FaltyDL’s and Sepalcure’s sounds were shaped by hearing deep bass on Love’s sound system. The rig didn’t just play the music. It taught people how to make it.

That openness ran the other direction across the Atlantic too, and this is the part I think gets undersold badly. While London was busy policing what technically counted as dubstep, Dub War was booking a second wave of British producers that London itself hadn’t gotten around to booking:

Younger artists who weren’t a part of the first wave of dubstep producers in London, and maybe felt like there wasn’t an opportunity for them to break into the scene there, got early support from us at Dub War. I think that we helped them find an audience and even respect within the London scene – people like Ramadanman, Pangaea, Untold, Darkstar, Scuba, Shackleton, Brackles & Shortstuff, Headhunter. These guys weren’t really getting booked at the big London nights, and in many cases they were known as fans more than serious producers, but we were playing their dubs and booking them at Dub War.

If those names don’t mean anything to you, that’s exactly the point, so let me translate what became of them. Ramadanman became Pearson Sound and co-founded Hessle Audio with Pangaea and Ben UFO. Untold started Hemlock. Scuba started Hotflush, which is where a lot of people first heard Mount Kimbie and Joy Orbison. Darkstar signed to Hyperdub and then Warp. Headhunter reinvented himself as Addison Groove and helped bring footwork to a European audience.

In 2006 and 2007, they were forum guys who produced music. Then a party in New York was flying them over and putting their names on flyers before the big rooms in their own city would.

Dave was also deliberate about keeping the thing rooted here, which is the part that makes it a New York story rather than a London franchise:

It was always important for me to do it in a way that felt authentic to the music culture of New York. The people who came were pretty intelligent music people. A lot of people who were older New York heads who had been involved in the experimental electronic music scene in New York in the ’90s were coming pretty early on. I loved that, because I was such a fan of what was happening in New York: with illbient, and experimental dub.

How the Word Got Out

Here’s something to consider: in 2006, Dub War had no press coverage, no social media algorithm, no promoter with a marketing budget. The greater dance music culture in America barely acknowledged the genre’s existence. So how were people in the Midwest, Canada, and London hearing about what was going on in a NYC basement?

Two people were the reason, and neither of them was hired.

Ken Seckle was a vinyl collector, Rinse FM obsessive who started showing up at Sputnik in the earliest days. He bonded with Dave and Joe over the fact that all three of them had separately made trips to Notting Hill Carnival in the late ’90s and early 2000s and had the same dub reggae awakening there. Then he just started recording everything. The line outside. Juakali introducing a DJ. A moment in somebody’s set. Joe talking about the vibe. He posted it to dubstepforum and to YouTube in 2007 and 2008.

This is back in 2007-08, when people were figuring out what YouTube actually was and how useful and powerful a tool it could be. People would watch the videos and see everything that was happening at Love.

Ashes57, a French-born graphic designer, discovered Dub War on the forum while still living in London, moved to New York, met Dave at a freezing DMZ vs. Dub War night, and was asked to make the next flyer a few days later:

I pretty much had carte blanche and I was lucky that he liked my work. I wanted to create art that represented the movement and the artists featured on the night. It was my way to contribute to the scene: transcribing the sound to graphics. The vibe was dark, with hints of color carefully picked.

Seckle filming everything from the first night at Sputnik, and Ashes57 giving the flyers a visual identity you could recognize at a glance, is how a party with no budget cut through to people who would have never set foot in it.

Notice the pattern, because it’s the same one from the beginning of this piece. The room’s video archive, its visual identity, and its MC all arrived exactly the way the crowd did: they showed up, they cared, somebody offered them something to do, and they ran with it. No one was paid.

America’s Front Door

From 2006 to 2010, dubstep went global. New fans, new music, new parties, and, like jungle and UKG before it, the growing pains that come with a genre no longer being just a London sound.

New York wasn’t a stop on that expansion. It was the funnel.

After a set in San Francisco, Dave built a relationship with Miroslav Wiesner, who was starting a booking agency called Surefire. From that point, whenever Dub War booked a DJ, Wiesner would split the flight cost and book West Coast dates for them around the New York booking. Fintoni’s word for what Dub War became is outpost~the point at which the sound entered the country and got distributed outward from.

I want to make sure that lands, because it’s the single most under-rated fact in American dubstep history. A meaningful chunk of the early west coast circuit got put on flights a day-job guy in NYC was paying for out of pocket. Not a promoter with backing. A man with a demanding day job and a party he ran because he loved it.

I never came into this to be a promoter. Even when I was doing it I never thought about it, I was naive in a way. I could have thought about it as a career but I always had a gruelling day job and Dub War was my release.

Soundcheck as an Attraction

This is my favorite story from either article, and a model for the community I want to build with 5BD:

The best part of Dub War, in my opinion, wasn’t the show. It was the sound check, and we had a few people that figured that out. Dave and I would get to the club at 8PM and people were already waiting in line. We’d say, “Yo, we don’t open doors for another two hours!” But then we were like, “You know what? Fuck it, come in.”

Doors at ten. Line at eight. And they literally said fuck it, let em in.

Think about who those people are. They’re not there for any specific DJ; the opener doesn’t even come on for another two hours. They’re there to watch an engineer walk a rig through its range then Dave or Joe find out what the room gives back. That’s a level of love and respect most parties never discover is available to them, because most parties simply don’t care enough to notice.

Dave and Joe noticed, and then did what obviously felt right. That’s it. That’s the whole strategy and it costs nothing.

The End

When Love changed hands in early 2010, the new owners decided to turn it into a sports bar. The sound system was allegedly in decay by then and the atmosphere had begun to thin, not only within the club, but in the greater scene around it.

Dave was burnt out from holding two jobs. The club was falling apart. And he’d become, in his own words, “increasingly uncomfortable” with dubstep as it drifted towards the sound most of the country thinks of when they hear the word.

Fearing the atmosphere would completely hollow out, Dub War decided to end on a high note and scheduled their final party for that same June. Five years to the month from their first night at Sputnik.

For about a year afterward, Dave ran a smaller Brooklyn party called Twisup that carried the same spirit into the genre footwork [a Chicago creation] before truly taking a break. Not for good, as it turns out, but that era of the scene in NYC deserves its own piece.

Here’s how he actually felt about the whole thing:

People would always talk about Dub War as being on the front lines, but I never fully accepted that because I saw it, culturally, as a London thing. Even though I did everything I could to represent it in the right way, I always felt like a little bit of a tourist and that it was an American outpost of something that will never be ours – especially when the Americanization of dubstep started happening. […] The venue declining obviously really hurt my heart. The scene was feeling more fragmented and there wasn’t as much unity of purpose and togetherness amongst everyone in the room, as there had been for those years.

Is this the most honest thing anybody’s said about dubstep in America?

Yes.

Is he primarily measuring Dub War by who invented the sound?

Also, yes.

But you do not get credit for a scene by inventing the sound. You get it by building the room, paying for the flights, booking the people nobody else would book, and standing at the same level as the crowd for five years while working a full-time job. Every American who has ever felt sub-bass properly owes something to a night a guy in advertising ran out of a bar basement in Brooklyn, because he couldn’t believe nobody else had heard it yet.

Fintoni’s line on Dub War and DMZ together is that they were kindred spirits, moved to act not because it was the thing to do but because it felt right. No plan. The parties simply grew on their own and drew in people who felt something real coming out of those rooms.

Dub War closed, but what it was doing didn’t. Luke Nukem started Reconstrvct in Brooklyn, explicitly to carry the same torch, running warehouse parties on a rig called Tsunami. In 2011 Webster Hall began BASSment Saturdays. And in October 2012, a Bed-Stuy collective called Dub-Stuy launched at The Paperbox with Joe Nice on the decks, having built their sound system by hand. All are next up in this series. And the question underneath it all, the one I’ll get to eventually, is where sub-driven music has a home in NYC today.

Sources: Ali Gitlow, “Nightclubbing: Dub War,” Red Bull Music Academy Daily, 2016. Laurent Fintoni, “Transatlantic Vibrations: 10 Years of DMZ and Dub War,” FACT, 2015.